Check out our large menu

You can do so much more with homemade ice cream than simply putting it in a bowl or cone.

When you're ready to try something different, make The Ice Cream Cafe your first choice. You'll love our tasty creations, such as...

  • Ice cream sundaes with toppings like sprinkles, hot fudge or nuts
  • Hand-spun milkshakes using any of our unique flavors
  • Ice cream cakes to celebrate a birthday, holiday or surviving a Monday
  • Delicious home-made flavored popcorn, kettle corn, cheese and caramel corn
We also make treats like caramel pastries, cinnamon buns and chocolate-covered fruits and candies. Find out more about our current selection of ice cream sundaes, milkshakes and candies when you call 307-686-8110.

Classic Flavors

Birthday Cake

White cake base with sprinkles

Black Raspberry (GF)

Rich, creamy, and refreshing raspberry

Blueberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake base with blue berry variegate

Bubble Gum

Classic bubble gum with bubble gum pieces

Butter Pecan (GF)

Buttery and sweet pecan ice cream

Chocolate (GF)

Rich dark chocolate

Coffee Bean (GF)

Coffee base with espresso beans and dark chocolate chips

Cookie Dough

Cookie dough base and cookie dough chunks

Cookies & Cream

Vanilla base with cookies and cream chunks

Cotton Candy (GF)

Classic Cotton candy flavor, bright pink

Mint Chip

A classic flavor with dark chocolate chips

Mud Pie

Coffee base with Oreos and fudge

Nutty Cherry (GF) *Contains almonds

Cherry based with almonds

Salted Caramel (GF)

Most popular flavor, not too sweet and not too salty

Strawberry (GF)

Classic strawberry with strawberry chunks

Vanilla (GF)

Award of Excellence winner for Vanilla in 2018 from the National Ice Cream Retailers Association.

Seasonal Flavors

Pink Lemonade Sorbet (GF)(DF)

A refreshing flavor of pink lemonade

Orange Sherbet (GF)

Fresh Orange flavor

Treasure Chest

One day we deiced we wanted an ice cream filled with flavors, a lot of pieces and swirls. This ice cream has chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, Reese's, caramel sauce all in a vanilla based ice cream.

Lemon Up Cookie

Your favorite girl scout cookie in ice cream form. Our lemon ice cream with pieces of lemon up cookies

Almond Raspberry (DF) (GF)

Almond base with swirls of raspberry and chopped almonds, dairy free made with coconut milk

Chocolate (DF) (GF)

A new twist on chocolate, dairy free made with coconut milk

Butter Toffee

Creamy toffee flavor with a hint of sweet

Reese's

Vanilla base with Reese's sauces and chunks of Reese's

Rocky Road

There a lot of rocky roads in Wyoming but ours is the sweetest. Chocolate ice cream with marshmallow cream and almonds

Current Flavors

All ice cream is made in house, in Gillette Wyoming. We will do our best to keep this list updated weekly; however, based on sales and availability there may be changes that are not reflected immediately.

GF = Gluten Free; V = Vegan DF = Dairy Free